Thinking small to win big

The following was published on Firstlinks on 24 May 2023.

Sinclair Currie, Portfolio Manager

Conventional wisdom suggests that ‘time in the market’ is a less risky strategy than ‘timing the market’. Boom and gloom provide attractive entry and exit points but only if the timing is right. Accurately identifying market peaks and troughs is notoriously difficult. In our experience, gradually allocating more to markets during times of market distress and less when ‘everything is awesome’ is a preferable approach.

Small caps, and in particular, industrials, present an opportunity for investors at current levels. The Small Ordinaries benchmark has underperformed the ASX100 since November 2021. Notably, industrials have underperformed resources, which have been supported by thematics such as energy security, battery materials, and gold. In addition, adjusting to tighter monetary policy has weighed on small industrials. The recent underperformance presents a chance for investors to incrementally allocate to the sector.

Small Ordinaries

Falling liquidity signals capitulation

Investors’ willingness to trade reveals their confidence, or lack thereof, in the market. Rising liquidity can create a virtuous circle during a bull market, when abundant liquidity entices more capital into markets (attracted by lower trading costs). Yet when liquidity falls and markets are falling, the cycle works in reverse. Capital ceases to flow to (or exits) the market due to illiquidity concerns.

Small Industrials Quarterly Share Turnover

Since November 2021, liquidity in the small industrials sector has dropped meaningfully. Thus far in 2023, the daily average value of turnover for small industrials has been $704m, down a third (from $1,070m) during the same period in 2021. The decline in liquidity indicates that a lower amount of new money is being put to work in Small Caps. Contrarian investors have a better chance of picking up a bargain now, relative to last year.

Microcaps have been hit harder

Not surprisingly the decline in liquidity has been most pronounced for the smallest of small caps. 74% of the smaller small industrials (with a market capitalisation of less than $1 billion) had lower turnover in the last 12 months relative to the previous year. Adjusting for stocks which benefited from index inclusion, 85% of companies saw turnover decline. The impact on liquidity has been lower for the larger small companies, 63% had lower turnover (or 69% adjusting for index changes). Unsurprisingly, 37% of ‘larger’ small caps (market cap >$1bn) outperformed the benchmark relative to a mere 14% of the ‘smallest’ companies.

One of our holdings Quantum Intellectual Property Ltd, provides a case study of the current dynamic in microcaps. Quantum has a meaningful and growing share of the Australian Patent, Trade Mark and IP Legal Services market. Over the last year their share price has fallen by 19%, materially under-performing the small cap benchmark. On our estimates, the company trades on an attractive discount to earnings and yield metrics relative to the broader market, however its share turnover is 23% lower than the previous year. In a recent market update, the company reaffirmed expectations for organic growth, improving margins and further consolidation opportunities. The decline in liquidity merely reflects that the stock has fallen off the market’s radar in our view, creating an investment opportunity. Quantum is just one example of similar opportunities arising in the current market environment.  

Different exposures than large caps

The Australian stock market is heavily weighted towards highly profitable bank and resources stocks. The smaller end of the market has a wider range of exposures, from resource exploration stocks and retailers to fast growing technology businesses. The composition of the small caps benchmark evolves over time.  Furthermore, industrial companies are less risky than three years ago. We estimate that loss making companies are now only 5% of the small industrials’ universe, down from over 30% before the pandemic. The current small cap market has a lower exposure to risky, early stage or loss-making companies.

Following the recent underperformance of small caps, we see attractively priced opportunities relative to the large cap universe.  For example, Domain Holdings offers faster growth than REA Group (as it increases market penetration), yet it trades at a discount.  At the same time, small cap building materials companies in markets with high barriers to entry, trade at through cycle earnings multiples in the mid-teens, despite having more favourable industry structures relative to than their historical averages.

Smaller Companies have traditionally been more volatile and sensitive to the economic environment, which is expected to be challenging. There are valid reasons to be cautious. However, the small industrials benchmark is comprised of more robust businesses post the 2022 market correction.  Their underperformance relative to large caps and the withdrawal of liquidity suggests the market is already fearful. This presents us with an opportunity to increase our exposure to quality, but overlooked, businesses.

Important Information

This material has been prepared by NovaPort Capital Pty Limited (NovaPort) (ABN 88 140 833 656). NovaPort  is the holder of an Australian Financial Services Licence AFSL AFSL 385 329 and is regulated under the laws of Australia. 

This document does not relate to any financial or investment product or service and does not constitute or form part of any offer to sell, or any solicitation of any offer to subscribe for interests, and the information provided is intended to be general in nature only.  This should not form the basis of, or be relied upon for the purpose of, any investment decision. This document is not available to retail investors as defined under local laws. 

This document has been prepared without taking into account any person’s objectives, financial situation or needs.  Any person receiving the information in this document should consider the appropriateness of the information, in light of their own objectives, financial situation or needs before acting.  The document has not been independently verified.  No reliance may be placed for any purpose on the document or its accuracy, fairness, correctness or completeness. Neither NovaPort nor any of its related bodies corporates, associates and employees shall have any liability whatsoever (in negligence or otherwise) for any loss howsoever arising from any use of the document or otherwise in connection with the presentation.